The unique train toilet challenge

News - 29 April 2021

Het toilet raakt ons hele leven, maar we willen het toilet liever niet aanraken. Met andere woorden, we proberen afstand te houden van toiletten, vooral openbare toiletten. Toch stellen zij ons in staat om onze huizen te verlaten en te reizen. Wie met de trein reist, is gewend gratis toegang te hebben tot de treintoiletten, zeker op lange trajecten. Maar omdat ze als vies worden ervaren, worden ze veel te weinig gebruikt. Een dilemma voor spoorwegmaatschappijen zoals de NS en een uitdaging voor sanitairontwerpster en promovenda Marian Loth.

Sanitary designer ‘pur sang’

Marian Loth was uniquely in the position to respond to the toilet-dilemma posed by Dutch railway company NS. She studied Industrial Design Engineering at TU Delft where she graduated with her master’s graduation project on the design of a female urinal at the design department of Sphinx. Marian then became project and design manager of the 'lady p.' at Sphinx Maastricht. The lady p was launched at the Frankfurt ISH’99 Sanitation Fair where it won the Design pl+s award and worldwide media coverage.

Marian returned to TU Delft in 2009 when asked to work on a sanitation design research project co-funded by the Ministry of Infrastructure and Water Management and NS. Her aim was to improve the hygiene of NS train toilet facilities through ergonomic design research. Public transportation offers several advantages over commuting by car, the ability to go to the toilet while on the move certainly should be one of them.

Read Marian Loth's thesis:

Unique design research

So, how do you design a new improved toilet for an intercity train? To answer this question you need to know what train-toilet users really do. Marian and her team devised a completely new approach to sanitation research: they video-recorded people’s actions while using the toilet on a moving train provided by NS; real-live toilet use. Of course, privacy safeguards were in place, the footage was anonymised for instance. The resulting analysis of what people actually do in a toilet led to Marian’s design concept for a new, cleaner toilet incorporating a urinal and a sit-down toilet in the same space.

What do you do with your bag?

Funnily enough, a specific barrier to toilet use in the train is people’s luggage. The toilet and its floor are perceived as being a dirty space, so the design-research team saw travellers going to great lengths to find ways of handling their bags and coats whilst using the toilet. It’s insights into seemingly mundane and small things like this which made this study extra valuable.

Keep your distance: a new model for hygiene

People need to keep distance from each other and from the toilet. Marian designed and tested a novel hygiene model of sanitation, applying the knowledge gained from the observations and questionnaires.

In her design-research proposal, Hygiene (H) is described as a function of the Physical (P), Mental (M) and Social Distance (S).

Reducing these distances heightens people’s perceptions of hygiene. Her final train toilet design minimizes the underlying physical (P), and mental (M) distances between train toilet and dirt, while reducing the social (S) distance for travellers.

The toilet is clean

Marian recommended the following design solution for the NS train toilet:

A urinal combined with a sit-toilet, additional support options for hands, including horizontal and vertical support bars, and support platforms for children’s feet. It is designed to help people with limited mobility, and the visually impaired. The toilet is closed by a wide (round) sliding door to improve usability and related hygiene.

In 2016, Dutch Railways implemented Marian’s new toilet design concept in the latest model of their intercity trains. Now, after her PhD journey has come to a successful end, Marian is still fascinated by sanitary design and is looking into new research possibilities.